Citizen Participation in Regional Master Plans: Watch London and Bangalore

I think I speak for all my fellow planners that no plan ever created has ever had “enough” public participation. Inevitably, no matter how broad (or narrow) the planning outreach and engagement process, there will be someone or some groups who will not feel adequately consulted or included. I have been at the helm of planning processes and public forums where this sentiment has been publicly hurled, deservedly or not; surely, a terrible feeling. It often feels like a professional hazard of the job.

But knowing this, there are so many ways that planners around the world attempt to address the issue of inadequate public participation, not only to save oneself from public outcry but more importantly to ensure a collaborative plan that will more assuredly be implemented to meet constituents needs.

So we have a moment when two draft regional master plans have been released by two megacities of roughly the same size, on roughly the same day, with two completely different approaches to citizen feedback.

Bangalore (pop. ~10 million in 2017): Revised Master Plan for Bengaluru 2031 was released to the public on November 24, 2017 for a 60-day comment period. The sections of the plan are available online, however, the means of commenting are through a physical form that the potential commenter must download and mail back to the planning body, the Bangalore Development Authority (BDA). No official public consultations have been advertised by the BDA but several civic organizations have begun to help the public strategize on how to respond and comment effectively. This feedback strategy clearly puts the burden on the public to self-organize and respond in a way that will be “heard” by the planning authority.

London (pop. ~9 million in 2017): New London Plan was released to the public on November 29, 2017 for a 90-day comment period. In addition to sending comments by mail, the public has the ability to provide comments directly in the relevant section of the plan using smart-document technology and collate comments for future edits. On the day that the plan was released, the Planning section of the Office of the Mayor also announced 11 public consultation events between December 1 and February 5, 2018. By law, the comments received for the London Plan will be examined by an Independent Planning Inspector.

Surely, Bangalore and London are very different cities with different planning traditions and urban governance structures. I have no doubt that both processes will hear from constituents who say they were not informed of the plan. But the use of technology in London, which could easily have been adopted in Bangalore–India’s tech capital, and the convening of the public by the planning authority itself seems like a missed opportunity.

Planners everywhere can watch this master planning processes unfold and hopefully learn what they can do in their own cities.

17 thoughts on “Citizen Participation in Regional Master Plans: Watch London and Bangalore

  1. ACampbell

    In today’s digital age, the internet and technology have significantly impacted public participation in planning processes. The emergence of “thesis online” platforms, social media, and digital communication tools have opened up new avenues for engaging with the public. Planners can use online surveys, virtual town halls, and interactive websites to reach a broader and more diverse audience.
    Through thesis online
    resources, planners can gather valuable insights and feedback from people who may not have been able to attend in-person meetings due to geographical constraints, time limitations, or other reasons. This expanded reach allows for a more comprehensive and inclusive approach to public participation.

    Reply
    1. Anita

      Seeking assistance in academic endeavors has never been easier, and the phrase “annotated bibliography writing service” https://domyessay.com/write-my-annotated-bibliography exemplifies the accessibility and convenience that modern technology affords. As a graduate student navigating the intricate demands of research and scholarly writing, I’ve come to appreciate the invaluable support provided by such services.

      Reply
  2. ana167

    Thank you for the article! I have studied similar subjects! Unlike other submissions, however, I have a very unique impression of yours. I hope you will continue to share articles of this caliber with the public. globle

    Reply
  3. Caby Lane

    Salam. Əylənmək və ən yaxşı kazinoda oynamaq istəyirsiniz? Azərbaycanın ən yaxşı kazinosu haqqında obyektiv rəy təqdim edən https://mostbetazerbaijan.com/ saytına daxil olmağı məsləhət görürəm. Bu baxışda siz kazino oyunlarının müxtəlif aspektlərini öyrənəcəksiniz və bu, oynamağa başlamaq qərarına gəlməyinizə kömək edəcək.

    Reply
  4. Maria

    This article brightened my day, so I appreciate you sharing it. Reading the shorter articles and providing an explanation of the writers’ reasoning is something I do frequently only up

    Reply
  5. Karas

    Good day, if you are a student and tired of continuous writing assignments, I recommend you to use promo code https://nocramming.com/domyessay-promo-code . This great academic assignment service provides a discount on your work, which will save you a lot of effort and time. Don’t miss the opportunity to lighten your study load and get a well-deserved rest!

    Reply
  6. Paul43

    Salamlar, Bu sayt https://mosbetazerbaycan.com/mostbet-apk/ Mostbet APK faylını yükləmək haqqında məlumat axtaran hər kəs üçün qiymətli daşdır. Məqalədə təkcə ətraflı təlimatlar deyil, həm də Mostbet tətbiqindən istifadənin faydaları haqqında əlavə məlumatlar verilmişdir. Aydındır ki, sayt mobil mərc təcrübəsini artırmaq istəyən istifadəçilər üçün əsas resurs olmağa çalışır.

    Reply
  7. barbara jameson

    I’m incredibly impressed with the effectiveness of CoreChair https://corechair.com/ in alleviating my back pain. Its unique design offers targeted support to the pelvis, resulting in improved posture and reduced strain on the lower back. Since incorporating CoreChair into my workspace, I’ve experienced a significant increase in comfort and productivity.

    Reply
  8. namdosan1409

    The vast open-world environments in many car games provide a sense of freedom, allowing players to embark on thrilling road trips and exploration. Car Games

    Reply
  9. Maradonna

    I recently took a chernobyl holidays tour organized by this website, and it exceeded all my expectations. The tour was well-planned, with knowledgeable guides who provided insightful commentary throughout the visit. Walking through the abandoned streets of Pripyat and seeing the remains of the reactor was a surreal experience that left a lasting impression. If you’re considering visiting Chernobyl, I highly recommend booking through this website for a safe and informative tour.

    Reply
  10. quordle game

    I appreciate your post. I’ve read about a variety of similar topics! Unlike other articles, yours left me with a lasting impact. I hope you’ll continue to write interesting pieces like this one and others for us all to read!

    Reply
  11. Sam

    “300-440 Exam dumps” refer to a collection of study materials typically designed to help individuals prepare for the Cisco 300-440 exam. The Cisco 300-440 Exam dumps also known as “Implementing Cisco Enterprise Advanced Routing and Services” (ENARSI), is an examination focusing on advanced enterprise routing and services topics within the Cisco Certified Specialist – Enterprise Core certification track.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *